![]() |
| In Mordor, John Howe. |
No one considers themselves a villain. They may loudly proclaim themselves as the hero of the story—until their actions reveal otherwise. Hence the old saying, “actions speak louder than words.”
J.R.R. Tolkien’s orcs represent this regrettable aspect of humanity. Orcs understand falsity and disloyalty, the dishonor of leaving your comrades behind (“just left him lying: regular Elvish trick” one says, when they find Frodo “abandoned” by Sam) but they are incapable of exhibiting the behaviors they know are correct (leaving one of their own for Shelob’s lunch).
Tolkien poured a lifetime of thought into orcs. He wrestled with their origin, and whether they could be redeemed. At the end of his life decided they were bred from men, but are not men. Which is to say, they retain some aspects of humanity, but remain an other. No orcs in any of Tolkien’s published material develop a conscience or suddenly decide to befriend elves and men. Even if they had such a thought, they wouldn’t be capable of acting on it. They are corruptions of Melkor, mightiest of the Valar, and if they can redeemed it will not be in this world.
Rather than one-dimensional or cartoonish, this makes them different and interesting. Because they are not us, but a truly fantastic race without real-world parallel.
The best explanation of orcish evil comes from Tom Shippey, author of The Road to Middle-earth, in his essay “Orcs, Wraiths, Wights: Tolkien’s Images of Evil,” published in Roots and Branches: Selected Papers on Tolkien (Walking Tree Publishers, 2007). No surprise there.
Orcs aren’t meant to be analogous to a human race, but an abstract representation of particular human qualities. Orcish evil is a very human-like turning away from good. “Orcish behavior is human behavior, and their inability to judge their own actions by their own moral criteria is a problem all too sadly familiar,” Shippey says.
I love this; I find it thought-provoking. Unfortunately the writers of The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power apparently did not, and decided they needed to make orcs their own.
Shippey served as a consultant for the show in its early days. But ultimately the two sides parted ways; either he was not retained or he left of his own accord. The precise reasons remain shrouded in mystery but what I do know is: removing the world’s greatest Tolkien scholar cannot improve your show, if your goal is to put Tolkien on the screen at least. This is obvious with what has transpired over three seasons.
The Rings of Power reimagines orcs as more “complex,” independent beings. Instead of existing as bloodthirsty extensions of a Dark Lord's will, or a representation of the human tendency to turn away from good, the show gives them domestic lives, factions, and personal agency. In Season 3, the series introduces an orc who turns against Sauron and aligns with Elves. This is the opposite of what Tolkien created and in my opinion a diminishment of the source material, less sophisticated and far more banal. There is no examination of evil here, it’s the equivalent of pasting a modern conception of “evil” that we get in the likes of Breaking Bad or Game of Thrones over a Tolkien veneer. The bold contrasts are gone, replaced by a cloak of gray.
People complain about why modern fantasy all seems the same and this is Exhibit A. Subversion is a low-effort creative stratagem. Making orcs more like humans, and every race—dwarves and Elves too—more like humans, flattens Middle-earth, makes it un-fantastic, too much like our own world. It removes the deep symbolism and mythic resonance inherent in Tolkien and moves it closer to soap opera.
I find this boring, done to death. The Lord of the Rings is not Game of Thrones and that is its strength. It is Weirder, and the greater, more original work.
There is a lesson to be learned here.
Chesterton’s Fence advises against removing a fence, tradition, law, or institution until you understand why it was put up in the first place. I do not believe, and have seen no proof, that The Rings of Power showrunners understood Tolkien’s conception of evil (and the orcs are merely one aspect by the way, wraiths and wights others, per Shippey). Rather than wondering why orcs were there, and what purpose they may have served, they carelessly knocked the fence over and introduce new unintended problems, none of which they seem bothered to resolve. Having orcs “just like us” neuters the problem of evil. Orcish behavior should be stamped out, but The Rings of Power upends that moral clarity. What are we to do after the battle of Helm’s Deep?
With Shippey we might have retained a Tolkienian depiction of evil. Absent an ardent keeper of the lore, or even a Peter Jackson-ian admirer of the source material, we get what we have in The Rings of Power: Tolkien in name only.

"Subversion is a low-effort creative stratagem."
ReplyDeleteAnd that is just one reason why most modern fantasy doesn't interest me. It often feels like it's trying so hard not to be like the works of old, and that self-awareness irritates me immensely.
On a slightly different but related note, this is also why I can't stand "hard magic systems". By reducing magic to a quasi-scientific set of rules, it doesn't feel like magic anymore.
I haven't seen Rings of Power (and I don't want to) but I agree on hard magic systems. It takes the mystery and wonder out it. I won't say it can't be done well, but I will say it is done to often.
Delete