Buck and John Thornton, ready for adventure |
In other news, a few reviews of Flame and Crimson are starting to trickle in, and so far I've been very encouraged. These include three reviews on Amazon, two four star and one five star, and two reviews on Goodreads, both five stars. A few folks have reached out to me via Facebook messenger or email with very positive comments and support. I had one relatively critical review from a member of The International Robert E. Howard Fan Association, who wanted something more fannish, with more checklists, and thought it too much of an overview. I will say he raised some valid points. Flame and Crimson is not an encyclopedic resource, and it lacks a comprehensive bibliography. I believe the genre needs such a book, something like Grady Hendrix' Paperbacks from Hell perhaps. And I'm kicking myself for not including a list of recommended reading or a top 20 list of S&S stories in the appendix. Ah well.
Overall I'm very encouraged with the positive responses. If you at all enjoyed Flame and Crimson, the best thing you can do is leave me a brief review on Amazon or Goodreads or elsewhere. I appreciate all who have done so!
When I checked Goodreads earlier, the book info wasn't all there. I see now that it is. I've cross-posted my review there, too.
ReplyDeleteSorry it's a short review, but I don't see the value in hyper-long reviews on Amazon. Sometimes I expand a little more at my blog but I've mostly been training myself to keep 'em short-&-sweet.
I'll post a review once I finish it--I'm buried in semester work right now. I've enjoyed the first few chapters and some other sections I scouted a bit.
ReplyDeleteYou could always post a top 20 list here.
ReplyDeleteThanks guys!
ReplyDeletePaul, your review is awesome--and short and sweet means it will be read :)
Matthew, I'm going to do that.