"Wonder had gone away, and he had forgotten that all life is only a set of pictures in the brain, among which there is no difference betwixt those born of real things and those born of inward dreamings, and no cause to value the one above the other." --H.P. Lovecraft, The Silver Key
Sunday, April 6, 2025
My daughter has a Substack. Which is very cool.
Tuesday, March 25, 2025
Facebook ripped me off
I punched my name into this handy plagiarism detection tool published by The Atlantic, and like millions of other authors discovered Mark Zuckerberg ripped me off. The nerve of this douche!
There I am! Above the whiskey. Of which I now need a few shots. |
In case you missed the recent news, “Meta and its founder and CEO Mark Zuckerberg deliberately and explicitly authorized a raid on LibGen—and Anna's Archive, another massive digital pirate haven—to train its latest AI model.” Millions of books have been ingested into Llama 3 without author compensation, or even notification.
What makes it even worse is that the fine folks at Facebook (I almost wrote that without a sneer) could have put some thought into the decision. Taken a few extra weeks to do the right thing. But instead chose to behave like Somali pirates operating on the open ocean.
What the fuck, Zuck.
There is of course complexity to this. How does fair use apply to the output of generative AI? Is feeding a machine training data the equivalent of a person reading? Will slowing AI development with more rigorous author protections and safety guardrails put us behind foreign competitors like China?
But that’s a battle for someone else to fight. Me? I’m tired of the techo-obfuscation and the excuse-making. This is pretty close to outright theft. Facebook could have done this the legal and proper way but its leadership team chose to operate like immoral assholes. Which should surprise no one.
I've written before that I'm not a fan of generative AI, even though I believe it has incredible potential and is here to stay. It’s just beyond galling that big companies like Meta and OpenAI scrape data from wherever and whomever they want and then sell it back to you in the form of subscription products. And then rigorously defend their own gated fiefdoms with impenetrable legalese and teams of lawyers.
The moral of the story: Laws don’t apply to big companies like they do individuals.
Honestly I am not THAT pissed. Just looking on, feeling bemused, disappointed and disempowered, sort of like the victim of a drive-by egging. Perhaps Llama 3 will now create some kick ass S&S haikus using the genre elements I outline in Flame and Crimson. Maybe there will be a class action suit and I will be entitled to a $3.87 payout after the lawyers take their share. We’ll see.
Sunday, March 9, 2025
We're living in an outrage machine
Tanith Lee = anti-outrage. |
Sunday, February 23, 2025
Some recent acquisitions
![]() |
The three other images below are postcard ads included w/Lee volume. |
![]() |
When My Body’s Numb and My Throat is Dry, I grab a Trooper. |
Friday, February 21, 2025
Paper books are better than digital: Five reasons why
Friday, January 24, 2025
Branching out in my reading, and reaching a crossroads
Squint, and it's Conan? |
Although I prefer fantasy I’m not someone who thumbs my nose at literary fiction (though I wish that worked the other way). As an English major I was exposed to wide range of authors, and loved almost everything I read, from Greek tragedies and Homer to Romantic and Victorian poetry to Hemingway and the modernists. I will pick up contemporary literary/realist works if I find the subject matter sufficiently interesting.
What interests me most is good writing. Genre is not unimportant, but is secondary. A decade or two ago I was reading every S&S title I could get my hands on, but at present moment I’d rather read a well-written novel than mediocre S&S, or yet another generic epic fantasy series.
Tangible example: I’m currently reading and nearly finished with John Williams’ Stoner. I picked this up following a booktube recommendation and frankly I’m blown away by how good it is. It’s a quiet character study, and yet the emotion and intensity—all within the breast of the protagonist—are equal to epic fantasy. Stoner’s created fictional world of college professordom, if not as original as Barsoom, is just as carefully constructed. The (petty) evils of Stoner’s jealous, flawed, and self-centered wife are as wicked and greedy as Sauron. It is full of wonders of a different and more ordinary but no less potent sort.
But my broad reading palette leaves me in a bit of a bind here.
On the one hand, this is my own damn blog, and can write about whatever I want. It’s unmonetized, I have no obligations to fulfill. If you don’t like the subject matter of a given post, it’s easy to skip it.
On the other hand, visitors and readers have a reasonable expectation of discussion of speculative fiction and other fantastic content (I include heavy metal under this broad tent). If I started for example writing about the NFL here it would get downright weird on a blog named after an HP Lovecraft short story.
Do I review Stoner here? Or John Gardner’s On Moral Fiction? I don’t know. I don’t really want to start a new blog—I don’t have the energy and I suspect it would be infrequently updated. But that might be a better option.
Is this question even worth asking? Eh. Probably not. Nevertheless I welcome your opinions, and beer recommendations.
Sunday, December 29, 2024
The Silver Key: 2024 in review
Saturday, December 7, 2024
Of the year in writing, and reading--memoir update and more
Thursday, October 3, 2024
The haunting season is here, in Lovecraft Country
![]() |
Heading to a trail behind my home, in Essex County. |
I’ve been reading some Lovecraft to get in the mood for the season, Bloodcurdling Tales of Horror and the Macabre. The 1982 Del Rey edition with the wraparound Michael Whelan cover that serves as the main canvass for the subsequent line of paperbacks.
![]() |
Home to a Deep One? |
![]() |
Don't cross that gate... |
![]() |
Alone on the path? |
Friday, May 24, 2024
The Light is Fantastic—stay positive
Wednesday, May 22, 2024
Humans are meant to do hard things
In my professional life I serve a profession called medical coding. No need to look it up; it’s quite niche and rather impenetrable to the outsider, though very important to the quality and financial health of hospitals.
I hear complaints all the time from medical coders about the difficulty of the work, and proposed fixes that would make everything better.
“If only the doctors would document acute systolic heart failure!” “If only the official coding guidelines were clearer about which diagnosis to report as principal!” “If only the insurance companies and hospitals could all agree on the definition of sepsis…
… then all our problems would go away!”
I don’t blame them for lodging these complaints, or for wanting fixes.
But what they don’t realize is they’d be replacing their day-to-day problems with a much bigger problem. Removing all the hard things would cost them their jobs. Because medical coding could be safely automated away.
And it would also cost them part of their life’s purpose, and stunt their development toward becoming an actualized human being.
I agree that their work is complex and often quite frustrating. Byzantine and possibly overly and needlessly complex in some aspects.
In need of some fixes.
But in general I see things with a different lens.
These “problems” are a good thing. Hard is a good thing.
Coding is not only a well-paying career, but for many actually meaningful too. Granted not for all; many consider medical coding, clinical documentation integrity and other like/adjacent professions (trauma/oncology registry, for example) mere work. They’d rather be doing something else, they work for the money and for the weekend.
But others have launched meaningful careers, made lifelong personal and professional relationships, in this line of work. Grew as people, became better versions of themselves, through the struggle of mastering their profession.
As have I.
What happens if it all goes away? And the machines take the work?
You might say, this is just how the world is, and how professions evolve. One line of work is replaced by another, displaced by technology. Some “optimists” argue: We can now spend our time doing more meaningful work instead of these lower-order tasks.
There is some truth to this, but this line of reasoning falls apart when entire human skillsets are outsourced to machines.
Let’s use the example of something more meaningful to readers of this blog: Writing and the visual arts.
If I just enter a series of prompts, and then prompt the AI for additional clarity, and publish a book in a weekend, this is not a meaningful achievement. If I can summon Dall-e to create an image, I did not create the art, the machine did.
You put in no sweat equity worthy of celebration. Had no stumbles, and failures, and doubts, and anxieties that, when you finally overcame them and published the work, made it your crowning achievement. Regardless of whether you ever sold a copy you did something amazing.
You created something and did something hard. You.
We need to do hard stuff.
Doing hard work will disproportionately reward people with greater ability. This leads to inequity … but that’s the way it has to be.
We don’t need to spend all our waking hours doing hard things (I would not be opposed to a four day workweek, for example). Nor am I calling for an end to technological development. Some jobs will inevitably be eliminated by labor saving technology. We don’t need to return to the good old days of horse-drawn wagons and polio.
If we could replace meaninglessly hard work, I’d be in favor of any such labor-saving device. I’m sure the suffering laborer would too.
But no one seems to have a plan for a world post work. Or far more frighteningly, life without difficulty. No one has addressed the fundamental underlying truth that doing hard things is good for us.
There is no intellectual I’m aware of who has painted a compelling--let alone non-dystopic and sane—picture of what a post-scarcity society would look like, and what it would mean for human flourishing. Could we still create believable, heartfelt art without any relationship to struggle? If we didn’t even know what struggle was, because everything was easy, available with the push of a button?
I would not call such a society a utopia, but a terrible dystopia.
The most beautiful human art is about struggle, and loss, and sometimes overcoming it. Even if the victory is only temporary.
Without anything hard to do, we’ll all be eating soma.
Monday, May 6, 2024
Some blogging odds and ends
Some stuff that might be interesting to you, but at minimum is important to me.
I’m not going to Howard Days this year. I was never planning to do so, but enough people have asked me that I figure I’d make it official here. I LOVED my first Howard Days experience and would gladly go again, but time and budget won’t permit me to go every year. I’ll just have to enjoy it vicariously and remember my experience of a year ago, which Deuce Richardson recently recapped on the blog of DMR Books in fine fashion here and here.
No book review requests, please. A public message that I’m not accepting any further books for review at this time. Recently I’ve received several requests to review new S&S and S&S adjacent titles, from authors and publishers, even a work in progress. I just don’t have time, due to personal and professional obligations. For more reasons why I made this decision please read this prior post. This is not to say I won’t be reviewing books here on the Silver Key, but they will be books I voluntarily seek out.
A terrific Mad Max conversation. I listen to a fair number of podcasts on topics that range from political to self-improvement to all things fantastic. Weird Studies with hosts Phil Ford and J.F. Martel has remained in my rotation when others have fallen out because the hosts are so damned good—even though I probably skip 50% or more of the episodes. I’m just not interested in the occult or tarot or TV shows I haven’t watched (i.e., most of them), but when these guys turn to a topic I love—i.e., the Mad Max film franchise—I’m in. This episode does not disappoint, even though it’s (as always) lit-crit heavy and intellectual AF.
A one-star review and 5-star feedback. I got my first one-star review of Flame and Crimson on Goodreads, from an individual whose review reads, “Meh, DNF.” This bothered me to some degree; I would never one-star a book I didn’t finish. But whatever, the book is definitely not for everyone and evidently was not for this dude. On the other hand, this recent email from a reader warmed my cold heart all the way through:
Hi Brian, I just wanted to tell you I'm on my second read through of "Flame
and Crimson" and I'm enjoying it equally as much. I first read CONAN in the
late 1960's as a teenager and found a world and a hero to identify with on
an internal level. Here were stories that led me to realms of the fantastic
and a cast of characters to cheer or boo, they even convinced me buy some
weightlifting gear. (I never achieved the frame of the fabled warrior.) So
many thanks for the research, the writing and the publishing of this
wonderful book. It makes a 70 year old feel young and vital again.
That makes it all worth it, including the one-star reviews.
Blind Guardian powers into Worcester MA on Saturday. My personal heavy metal tour makes its next stop at The Palladium in Worcester this weekend, where I’ll be taking in legendary German power metal band Blind Guardian. With my old friend Dana, who introduced me to these guys a couple decades ago to my delight. Thanks Dana. Any band who writes concept albums based on J.R.R. Tolkien’s The Silmarillion gets my attention, and these guys are always amazing.
I’ve got a college graduate. My oldest daughter Hannah, 22, just graduated from Colby-Sawyer college with a degree in professional and creative writing, and already has a job offer which she’s accepted teaching at a local boarding school. I couldn’t be prouder. She’s both like her Dad and very much her own person and I’m looking forward to watching her continue to grow into young adulthood. I’m a lucky man.
Wednesday, February 28, 2024
50 years of Savage Sword of Conan, and beyond
Issue 29 TOC. |
That map made me a child of sorcery... |
Conan's Ladies... easy on the eye. |
Holy balls that's some good artwork... Almuric at left (Tim Conrad) |
I desperately wanted to participate. |
Would they still honor these prices? |
RIP John Verpoorten. I'd read every article, regardless of subject matter. |
Swords and Scrolls... first letter by one Andrew J. Offutt. With praise for issue #24 and "Tower of the Elephant." |
Monday, February 12, 2024
A few updates and a space Viking
Tuesday, January 30, 2024
Authenticity, Inward and Outward
Tuesday, January 16, 2024
Organizing my bookshelves: How I do it (YMMV—no hate)
Tor Conan, ERB, CAS, Moorcock... and more. |
Ahh, love that Nasmith-illustrated Silmarillion. |
Part of my S&S bookcase... lots of REH, KEW, Anderson. |
The horror! Is that a figurine in there? |
More books... |